Is Platinum Better Than White Gold For an Engagement Ring?
White gold is a wonderful metal, and has a fascinating manufacturing process. At the same time, platinum is an equally intriguing metal. But is platinum better than white gold for an engagement ring? Both have a level of class purchased at the high end of the spectrum, and both are highly resistant to tarnishing (even capable of withstanding contact with sulfuric acid). But is one better than the other? Let’s look at what each one says, and briefly consider their composition.
Seeing as gold production is only approximately 82 million troy ounces per year (note that a troy ounce is only 32 grams), gold most certainly makes a statement about its owner’s ability to keep the bills paid. And of course, even the word “gold” says something about a sparkle that the eye can’t quite detect. There is a mystique surrounding the metal that people save two months’ salary to put on one another’s finger.
But of course, since only 5 million troy ounces of platinum are mined each year, having platinum doesn’t just say, “I have money or I have payday loan online.” A piece of platinum jewelry says, “If I grow any wealthier, I may run out of ways to show it off.” But rarity alone says nothing about the genuine quality of the materials, does it? Perhaps white gold is simply a more easily acquired metal.
White gold does not occur anywhere in nature. It is actually a combination of gold and another metal, then it is electroplated with rhodium to be white. White gold alloys come in several different varieties, and can be used for vastly different purposes. Keep in mind that the rhodium tends to wear off, often in as little as a year… meaning it has to be replaced over and over again.
Some white gold involves alloying it (combining two metals by melting both and combining them) with nickel, which gives it great strength and rigidity, which works well in rings and pins. If gold is alloyed with palladium, however, it becomes soft and pliable, which is ideal for diamond settings.
Platinum, however, is naturally white. It needs no combination, and can be used essentially pure. Technically, it tends to have traces of other metals within, making it approximately 95-98% pure. But gold is nearly always combined – 24 carat gold (99% pure) can be warmed slightly and molded like a child’s putty. 18ct gold is 75% pure, and 14ct gold is 58.5% pure.
So, white gold should be far less expensive than platinum, as it is higher maintenance, tends to have less tolerance to abrasion, it tends to only be about half actual gold, and tends to look like silver after only a few years.
So, is platinum better than white gold for an engagement ring? It is your choice to decide which metal is right for you. Obviously white gold has the cost benefit and platinum requires less upkeep and is more durable.